Hidden Gems: The 10 Most Underrated Albums Audiophiles Need to Hear

In the vast landscape of music, some albums manage to slip through the cracks despite their exceptional quality. These hidden gems often receive little attention or commercial success, yet they resonate deeply with those who discover them. You have some of the best speakers in the world, so why not put them to good use and give these artists a try? Whether you're a seasoned music lover or someone looking to expand your musical horizons, these underrated albums are worth adding to your collection. Here are some of the most overlooked masterpieces that deserve a listen.

1. Jeff Buckley - "Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk" (1998)

Overview

Following the success of his debut album, "Grace," Jeff Buckley was working on his second album when he tragically drowned in 1997. "Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk" is a posthumous compilation of unfinished tracks and demos, showcasing Buckley's exceptional talent and the potential direction his music could have taken.

Highlights

Songs like "Everybody Here Wants You" and "The Sky Is a Landfill" highlight Buckley's incredible vocal range and emotional depth. The album's raw and unfinished nature gives it an intimate and haunting quality that fans of his work will appreciate.

2. Nick Drake - "Bryter Layter" (1971)

Overview

Nick Drake's "Bryter Layter" is often overshadowed by his other albums, "Five Leaves Left" and "Pink Moon." However, this sophomore effort is a beautifully orchestrated blend of folk, jazz, and rock, featuring contributions from members of Fairport Convention and John Cale of The Velvet Underground.

Highlights

Tracks like "Northern Sky" and "One of These Things First" showcase Drake's delicate guitar work and melancholic voice, complemented by lush arrangements and sophisticated production. "Bryter Layter" is a melancholic yet uplifting album that captures Drake's unique artistry.

3. Big Star - "#1 Record" (1972)

Overview

Despite critical acclaim, Big Star's debut album, "#1 Record," failed to achieve commercial success upon its release. However, it has since gained a cult following and is considered a cornerstone of power pop and alternative rock.

Highlights

Songs like "Thirteen" and "In the Street" combine catchy melodies with heartfelt lyrics, showcasing the band's knack for crafting timeless pop tunes. The album's influence can be heard in the music of artists like R.E.M. and The Replacements.

4. Fiona Apple - "Extraordinary Machine" (2005)

Overview

Fiona Apple's third album, "Extraordinary Machine," was delayed and reworked several times before its release, resulting in limited initial exposure. Despite this, it is a masterful collection of songs that highlight Apple's distinctive voice and intricate songwriting.

Highlights

Tracks like "O' Sailor" and "Extraordinary Machine" blend orchestral arrangements with Apple's introspective lyrics and piano-driven melodies. The album is a testament to her artistic resilience and innovation.

5. Love - "Forever Changes" (1967)

Overview

"Forever Changes" by Love is a psychedelic rock masterpiece that was largely overlooked upon its release but has since gained recognition as one of the greatest albums of all time. Its intricate arrangements and poetic lyrics set it apart from other albums of the era.

Highlights

Songs like "Alone Again Or" and "A House Is Not a Motel" showcase the band's unique blend of folk, rock, and orchestral elements. The album's introspective and existential themes make it a timeless and compelling listen.

6. Nina Simone - "Baltimore" (1978)

Overview

Nina Simone's "Baltimore" is an underrated gem that blends jazz, blues, and reggae influences. Despite its lack of commercial success, the album features some of Simone's most powerful performances and poignant lyrics.

Highlights

The title track, "Baltimore," is a haunting commentary on urban decay, while "Everything Must Change" and "Rich Girl" showcase Simone's versatility and emotional depth. The album's eclectic mix of styles and Simone's commanding presence make it a standout in her discography.

7. Elliott Smith - "Either/Or" (1997)

Overview

"Elliott Smith's "Either/Or" is a critically acclaimed album that remains somewhat underappreciated compared to his later work. The album features Smith's signature introspective lyrics and delicate acoustic arrangements.

Highlights

Songs like "Between the Bars" and "Say Yes" are poignant and beautifully crafted, highlighting Smith's talent for writing deeply personal and relatable music. "Either/Or" is a testament to his enduring influence and artistry.

8. Tame Impala - "Innerspeaker" (2010)

Overview

Before achieving mainstream success with "Currents," Tame Impala's debut album, "Innerspeaker," was a psychedelic rock tour de force that flew under the radar. The album is a vibrant and expansive exploration of sound.

Highlights

Tracks like "Solitude Is Bliss" and "Lucidity" showcase Kevin Parker's knack for blending catchy melodies with psychedelic textures. "Innerspeaker" is a must-listen for fans of modern psychedelic rock.

9. PJ Harvey - "Is This Desire?" (1998)

Overview

PJ Harvey's "Is This Desire?" is an atmospheric and introspective album that didn't receive as much attention as her earlier work. The album explores themes of love, longing, and spirituality through haunting and evocative music.

Highlights

Songs like "The Wind" and "Angelene" feature minimalist arrangements and Harvey's powerful vocals, creating a haunting and immersive listening experience. "Is This Desire?" is a deeply emotional and underrated gem in her catalog.

10. Sufjan Stevens - "The Age of Adz" (2010)

Overview

Sufjan Stevens is known for his folk-inspired albums, but "The Age of Adz" takes a bold departure into electronic and experimental territory. The album is a sprawling, ambitious work that blends orchestral elements with glitchy electronics.

Highlights

Tracks like "Futile Devices" and "Impossible Soul" showcase Stevens' ability to fuse traditional songwriting with avant-garde production. "The Age of Adz" is a challenging but rewarding listen that highlights his versatility as an artist.

Conclusion

These underrated albums represent just a fraction of the hidden gems waiting to be discovered in the vast world of music. Each one offers a unique listening experience, showcasing the creativity and talent of the artists behind them. By exploring these lesser-known masterpieces, you can expand your musical horizons and find new favorites to cherish. So take a chance on these hidden gems, and let their music enrich your life.


Brian Goldrick

Brian is a passionate audiophile who has fitted home audio installations for the past 30 years. Now tired of lifting heavy HiFi systems and cutting holes in walls he spends his time traveling with his family and testing new audio products in an advisory capacity.

Previous
Previous

The 12 Best MIDI Controllers of 2024: Beginner to Professional

Next
Next

The Evolution of the Mixtape: From Cassette Tapes to Digital Playlists